Doreen Massey, socialist feminist, engaged geographer and influential public intellectual has died, during the night of March 11th, aged 72. Tributes are pouring in through social media. ‘Now we understand what everyone else felt about David Bowie’, was one attempt to convey the scale of our loss. Doreen’s body could sometimes be frail but her mind was brilliant and tough. As a character she was strong, passionate, curious and also imbued with modesty and kindness. She radiated political energy and humanity, sparkling with a cheeky wit.
With a steady flow of books, such as For Space, The anatomy of job loss, andSpace, Place and Gender and contributions to the books of others such as Huw Beynon’s Digging Deeper, a collection on the politics of the 1984/85 miners strike, she worked alongside others such as David Harvey, to establish geography as the intellectual source of a powerful, integrated critique of predatory capitalism in the age of climate change and the corporate driven global market.
Her academic base was the Open University to which she was strongly loyal because of its openness and accessibility to all who wanted to learn. She turned down professorships from elsewhere, including from Oxford, which she considered too exclusive and elitist for her far-reaching educational mission.
She became a mentor, both through her writings and through a tireless round of talks and personal conversation, to generations of young geographers; their appreciation is evident in the Twitter storm that has followed the shock of her death.
She was proud of winning the Prix Vautrin Lud (‘Nobel de Geographie’) and she organised a celebration with her large and varied circle of friends in typically convivial Doreen style. On the other hand, she was appalled to hear that the vehemently hated establishment wanted to award her an OBE. The result was an urgent phone call to get contact details of other refuseniks of royal awards Ken Loach, John Palmer and more in order to plan how to ensure that her refusal had a maximally anti-royalist impact.
Her strong sense of class underpinned all her politics; it drove her energetic support for the women in the mining communities during the 1984/85 strike (we went together to Blidworth in Nottinghamshire to give moral and practical support to the local pickets and Women Against Pit Closures); and it was one reason for her enthusiasm for Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership of the Labour Party and the possibilities it opened up. (Indeed the last time I was with her was when together with Chantal Mouffe, another close Kilburn friend, we discussed what we could DO to support Corbyn’s leadership.)
She wrote a heartfelt call to intellectual arms in her last Soundings blog: ‘Corbyn’s commitment to democratic engagement and openness, and to doing politics in a different way,’ she argued, ‘as well as his rejection of individual celebrity status, is a real strength…
‘We must do everything we can to keep this initiative growing and to play our part in the wider movement that keeps bubbling up.’
But she did not just make editorial calls from the platform of Soundings, the thoughtful and imaginative quarterly journal that she founded with Mike Rustin and the late Stuart Hall (published by Lawrence and Wishart’s Sally Davison). She and fellow Kilburn residents, Mike Rustin and Stuart Hall, worked hard and with an impressive sense of urgency to produce the path-breaking and remaking Kilburn Manifesto: path-breaking because of the way it challenged the dominant terms of debate and deconstructed the language of neoliberalism. As she wrote:
‘Think, for instance, of that bundle of words “investment/expenditure/speculation”. Each term bears moral connotations: investment good thing; expenditure a cost, possibly a burden; speculation in a financial sense a bit dodgy. Now think about how we use these terms in popular and political discourse.
‘The couplet investment/expenditure for example. Investment, in the national accounts, is money laid out for things such as buildings and infrastructure. Expenditure on the other hand is money laid out, for instance, on the wages of people operating the services for which the investment provides the infrastructure. So building a new school is investment (moral connotation: a good thing) but paying for teachers and dinner ladies is expenditure (a pure cost, a burden). (Ponder, immediately, the gender implications of this.)’
The radical, socialist and labour movement think tank CLASS (Centre for Labour and Social Studies) was another important platform for Doreen and her work for them was greatly appreciated by its staff.
Her upbringing in Wythenshaw, one of the largest council estates in Manchester, was a constant reference point in our political discussions and I think it fired her fury at class exploitation and the exercise of ruling class power, intertwined in complex ways with the inequities of economic geography and of gender and race. The North West remained a focus for several of her life-long passions. There were constant train journeys from Euston to Liverpool to cheer on her football team, to which she was fiercely loyal and then on to Ulveston, to stay with her much loved sister Hilary, go walking with her and do a bit of bird watching (another of Doreen’s enduring loves) in the inspiring fells of the Lake District.
She was also passionate about London, her city of residence and often of study. She was an active architect and engineer of the Greater London Council under the leadership of her friend and Kilburn neighbour, Ken Livingstone. She became a member of the Greater London Enterprise Board on which fellow board member John Palmer remembers how she ‘would ask searching questions on issues surrounding the advancement of the rights of women and ethnic minorities in the preparation of development strategies for GLEB investments.’ And Robin Murray, also a member of the board as Economic Advisor to the GLC, describes how she ‘insisted that space was social not just physical: gendered space, class space’. She brought these perspectives, which enlightened so many, to the deliberations as they considered how the GLC’s principles could be translated into the concrete projects that came before it.
Several of us, including Robin and one of her co-founders of Soundings Mike Rustin also remember the group that met with Ken Livingstone in her front room after Mrs Thatcher’s abolition of the GLC, and how, in Robin’s words, ‘a great theorist was equally at home in discussing the key political issues of the day’.
She applied this ability to combine theoretical innovation and political engagement on an international scale, especially in Latin America. She spoke fluent Spanish and spent a year in Nicaragua, writing a book about it. Her continuing interest in space and power led her to a long standing engagement with political change in Venezuela. I remember how chuffed she was that her concept of power-geometries was taken up as part of the effort to extend grassroots democracy and participatory democracy. She was also a member of the editorial board of the journal Revista Pos, the School of Architecture and Urbanism of Sao Paulo, Brazil.
In addition to her long involvement with Latin America, she also worked with South African activists. During the transitional government, she worked with Frene Ginwala, later the first person of colour to become Speaker of the South African Parliament, in a workshop on gender and unpaid labour, at a time when such issues were sidelined in economic debate. ‘It was an extraordinary event,’ remembers another friend, Maureen Mackintosh, also involved with the struggles in Southern Africa.
On a personal note, I came to know Doreen through both of us becoming trustees of a charity whose mission was to fund education and research about socialism. And it was through the Trust that we discovered we shared the same birth date. Our two older trustees at the time, doughty historian John Savile, and magisterial Marxist political theorist Ralph Miliband, suggested a date for the winter meeting: January 3rd. We both muttered somewhat grumpily, ‘but that’s our birthday’. But as good soldiers to John Savile’s military command, we went along with it. After a birthday drink we arrived at the meeting at the Miliband/Kosack home, to be greeted in the most chivalrous manner, by John and Ralph presenting each of us with a large bouquet! It was a fond memory of these two comrades over which we often had a good chuckle.
How we will miss that chuckle! But we are fortunate that through the stunning (a favourite word of hers) range and scope of her writing, her ideas are still with us, though we are able to reinforce her influence. So she would want me to end this salute and make sure it resounds, with a sharp political remark. The opening of her recent Soundings blog would do the job: ever since Corbyn was elected, pundits have been predicting doom for Labour. In fact Labour’s doom is more likely to be sealed if the party does not rally round and work to make his leadership successful. Whatever the party – and in particular the Parliamentary Party – does, friends of Doreen (a large and influential network) I know will rally round to remember Doreen and keep alive her determined spirit and ensure the continuing influence of her transformational and deeply radical politics. Viva Doreen! Viva the transformation of geometries of power! Viva!
This piece was also published by OpenDemocracy.
#230 Struggles for Truth ● The Arab Spring 10 years on ● The origins and legacies of US conspiracy theories ● The limits of scientific evidence in climate activism ● Student struggles around the world ● The political power of branding ● Celebrating Marcus Rashford ● ‘Cancelling’ Simon Hedges ● Latest book reviews ● And much more!
And you choose how much to pay for your subscription...
Hilary Wainwright remembers friend and mentor to many, Leo Panitch, who died on December 19, 2020
Co-creator of the Lucas Plan, Mike showed how the immense talent of workers could be deployed for social use rather than private profit, writes Phil Asquith
Seema Chandwani pays tribute to Narendra Makanji
A collection of highlights from Jeremy Hardy's columns for Red Pepper, and memories from his time in the movement
Mike Marqusee was an extraordinary writer and activist who enriched the left in the UK and internationally, writes James O'Nions
Everyone at Red Pepper is devastated by the loss of our inspiring columnist Mike Marqusee