Government passes the buck on corporate manslaughter bill

Changes in the law to make it easier to prosecute companies for manslaughter are now far less likely to take place before the next election as the government announced further delays to its bill that would make "corporate killing" a new offence.

July 1, 2004 · 3 min read

Home Office minister Baroness Scotland apologised to a conference organised in April by the Centre for Corporate Accountability that the draft bill had not yet been published. However, she said: “We are still hoping to publish a draft bill before the end of the current parliamentary session.” This means by the beginning of the next queen speech -around October 2004.

But Scotland emphasised that the government would remain committed to its manifesto commitment to reform in this area.

The Labour government first announced its intention to legislate in this area at the 1997 Labour Party conference. A year earlier the Law Commission had proposed that there should be a new offence of “corporate killing” which would allow a company to be prosecuted for a homicide offence without the need to prosecute a director or senior manager of the company.

One of the main reasons for the delay appears to be a conflict within government about whether “crown bodies” – government departments and organisations controlled by them – should be prosecuted for the new offence. Although it would be difficult to allow private companies but not government bodies to be prosecuted for a homicide offence (allowing private, but not Home Office, prisons to be prosecuted, for example), some ministers remain uncertain about removing crown immunity.

With only five small companies convicted for manslaughter, the proposal to enact a corporate killing offence has been widely supported by trade unions and safety groups. However, there is now much greater uncertainty about the contents of the draft bill.

There is concern, for example, that the government has rowed back on in its summer 2000 consultation document, which suggested that any new bill would increase not only the criminal accountability of companies, but also of company director and managers. The Home Office has made it clear that the government’s bill will not be directed at the conduct of company directors.

The new reforms will be nowhere near as radical as reforms passed by Canadian parliament in November 2003. The new Canadian legislation:

  • applies not only to “companies”, but also to all other organisations including “unincorporated associations” and all “public bodies”;
  • makes it easier to prosecute these bodies when serious negligence has resulted in death and/or in serious injuries;
  • imposes a legal duty upon directors and supervisors “to take reasonable steps to prevent bodily harm to that person, or any other person, arising from that work or task”;
  • and allows the courts to sentence the company to probation orders, requiring organisations to make far reaching changes to its policies and report them back to the court.
    • Share this article  
      share on facebook     share on twitter  
    The Gold Vaults of the Bank of England [Credit: Bank of England]

    Fighting the inequality pandemic: the case for a super-tax

    Keval Bharadia argues for a super-tax on financial markets to curb extreme inequality in the wake of Covid-19

    Black Friday demonstration against Deliveroo in Berlin in 2018. Photo by Leonhard Lenz

    The politics of Covid-19: gig work in the coronavirus crisis

    How long are we willing to turn a blind eye to the vulnerabilities of essential workers on the bottom of the employment hierarchy, asks the Fairwork Foundation

    Democracy in focus: follow the dark money…

    The UK’s unwritten constitution protects the world’s financial crooks and tax dodgers. Test your ability to expose them with our quiz, compiled by Adam Ramsay

    Election 2019: Tackling tech giant tax avoidance

    Conrad Bower reports on the main parties’ manifesto promises to address ‘aggressive’ tax avoidance by multinationals like the ‘Silicon Valley Six’

    Free the Soil Banner

    Taking on industrial agriculture

    As the XR International Rebellion continues, Katie Sandwell reports on the recent Free the Soil Action Camp which strengthened ties between food sovereignty and climate justice movements

    Labour once again refuses to break with ‘business as usual’

    Labour's links to PricewatehouseCoopers is yet another sign of a party unwilling to break from 'business as usual' and of a political system captured by corporate interests, writes Andrew Dolan