Tony Blair was not the first politician to use the same word three times for effect. Back in 1860 Abraham Lincoln wrote ‘work, work, work, is the main thing.’ Nearly a century and a half later it serves as an apt epitaph of Labour’s first term in government. But the gleaming hope that record levels of employment once held for policy makers now seems naive as workers from all backgrounds begin to question what kind of work and society we are creating.
New Labour sees work as the panacea to many of the problems it was elected to solve. And in a way it is right to do so. But so important has the concept of work become to the government that, as one Guardian commentator noted, ‘New Labour has elevated work into a kind of ideological glue to weld its policies together.’

A monthly dose of our best articles direct to your inbox
At the heart of this ideology is the notion that work is the means by which equality of opportunity is achieved. Personal, family and social salvation are all also supposed to be delivered through work. The only purpose of education is in order to produce a well-trained workforce. Work is the way to provide for retirement so that you do not become a burden on the state. Work is a means of keeping the youth off the streets, lowering crime and enabling social mobility. It is of little surprise therefore that so much effort has been expended in maximising the numbers returning to work.
All work, no life
But at what cost? A new class structure is fast becoming established to replace the antiquated social order of previous decades. This class structure is free from the constraints of age, geography, gender, ethnicity or even social background. Rather, its levels are defined both by income and by free time -by the summation of household income divided by waking time outside work. For far too many of us such a calculation would highlight the unbalanced nature of our lives. There is not a balance between work and the rest of our lives. One side or the other dominates -either we are in work and have enough money but little or no free time, or we are unemployed or retired with much time but scandalously little income.
The fact that work has become life for many is not something we should necessarily be proud of
The concept of work-life balance can be meaningless, practical and profound at the same time. It is meaningless in the sense that it is simply an umbrella term for the expectations, events, practices, structures and rules that stop us from getting the most out of work and the rest of our lives. Practically, the balance can be changed by intervening in areas such as working hours and leave entitlements (e.g. through the Working Time Directive), workplace stress, workplace discrimination, employees terms and conditions, health and safety concerns, pay levels and the Living Wage. But the work-life balance is also profound in the simplicity in which it encompasses both our work and our lives within our families and communities.
Earlier this year Richard Reeves published Happy Mondays, a book in which he claimed that ‘work gets a bad press.’ According to Reeves we work long hours because we enjoy it. There is no such thing as job insecurity and our friendships and other relationships are likely to be office-based. In actuality, as Reeves fails to note, only one third of employees feel secure in their job and nearly half of all men believe that they will have a period of unemployment. He also ignores the fact that two thirds of all employees feel that their working hours undermine family life. That work has become life for many is not something we should necessarily be proud of.
Towards true work-life balance
But what is the answer? In slaying their dragon, New Labour chose the numbers weapon. It is all about creating enough jobs for everyone so that pensioners and teenagers can work alongside one another in DIY superstores. But is this what we want? Certainly the blurring of gender, generation and ethnic lines is welcome, but are pensioners and teenagers working out of choice or necessity? If universities did not charge tuition fees or if the basic state pension was higher would DIY superstores lose their workforce?
In July, the Industrial Society published a book which claimed that our real goal within the work-life balance debate should be to achieve time sovereignty -the ability to choose how and when we work. This is certainly a central issue and has much to offer in the analysis of our contemporary lives. But if we are to enable individuals to be sovereign over their time we must pay them a living wage. Low hourly pay means more of our time is taken up by work whether we want it or not. But paying a living wage would go a great deal of the way to enabling workers to have real choice and time sovereignty.
But achieving a work-life balance is not simply a matter of being paid enough to take time off. It requires a new covenant between worker, employer and government -a balance between social partners that enables a personal balance. It is a sad indictment of contemporary corporate Britain that while increasing demands are placed on workers to be innovative, flexible and accountable, employers refuse to trust, value and empower their staff.
But fundamentally, the work-life balance is not just about work, it is about our whole lives. Time not at work is about pursuing other interests and with decentralisation of power away from Westminster there is increasing opportunity for us to participate in the development of our communities.
Work-life balance is about altering the nature of our work so that we can feel more fulfilled in our lives. It means ensuring a fair deal for those in work and providing choices for those who are not. It means blurring the generational divide so that we don’t have to postpone some ambitions until retirement, whilst others end with our sixty-fifth birthday. And it means a renewed concern about the quality of our lives and not just the quantity of our working hours.


