The Luddites: Everything you know is wrong!

In a guest post, Dave King from Luddites200 takes a fresh look at this movement as it approaches its 200th anniversary

November 18, 2011 · 3 min read

Legendary Yorkshire radical folk band Chumbawamba have a hilarious song satirising conspiracy theories, called ‘Everything you know is wrong’.  But if we’re talking about the Luddites, textile workers from Yorkshire, Lancashire and Nottinghamshire, who in 1811-13 smashed machines which were destroying their jobs, it’s probably true.

Nowadays most people think that the Luddites were ignorant vandals opposed to progress in, but this is a myth, invented in the 1950s.  It’s a history written by the victors: in fact, the Luddites opposed only ‘machines hurtful to Commonality’ ie. to the common good.  When they went into mills with their massive ’Enoch hammers’, they smashed only those machines that were destroying their trade, whilst leaving other machines untouched.  Unlike this summer’s rioters, they even punished those in their ranks who stole small items during the raids.

Although their uprising was repressed by massive state violence, (50 people were hanged and more transported to Australia), the Luddites’ spirit lives on, for example in the highly successful anti-GM food and anti-nuclear campaigns. 200 years later as the industrial capitalist system they were fighting has led to global warming, exhaustion of natural resources and biodiversity collapse, as well as huge exploitation and injustice, their sceptical approach to its mythology of ‘progress through technology’ looks more and more relevant.  Can we discard that mythology but still go forward, not ignoring the benefits of some technologies, but creating a world in which technology development is democratically controlled?

There are more parallels.  In 1812, Britain was in deep recession, caused by trade blockades that were part of the Napoleonic Wars.  Bad harvests had sent the price of bread through the roof, and unemployment often meant starvation.  Then, trade unions were illegal, but the workers had repeatedly petitioned Parliament to enforce existing laws banning machines that destroyed jobs, with no success.  In 2011, as part of the strategy to cut public-sector jobs, librarians like Paul Walker from Bristol are being told that they are no longer needed, due to the introduction of self-service machines.  Insanely, even coastguards are being replaced by communications technology.  The Economist recently came as close as it ever could to admitting the so-called ‘Luddite Fallacy’ that economists like to talk about is not a fallacy after all.

Luddites200 is a group of technology politics campaigners, trade unionists, scientists, engineers, artists and others, who have come together to challenge the lies about the Luddites.  We want to open a real debate about which technologies are appropriate in a transition to a sustainable and just society.  Two days before the Leeds Summat we’re holding a benefit gig at TJs at which Boff and Phil of Chumbawamba, as well as Seize The Day front man Theo Simon and Yorkshire folk singer, Gary Kaye will be supporting our call to celebrate the Luddites’ 200th anniversary.  We’ll also have a bunch of younger Leeds acts like Dan Audio, Raphael Attar, Docterre and Halifax punks Three Sheets t’ Wind.  We hope you can join us, or come to our workshop at The Leeds Summat to learn about the real story of the Luddites and their relevance today.

 

 


The NHS has become complicit in the exploitation of migrant workers

As a wave of strikes is planned across London, Petros Elia – an organiser with the United Voices of the World Union, outlines racist outsourcing practices that implicate some of our biggest ‘socially responsible’ employers

Global Justice Rebellion activists

It’s time to add global justice to XR’s demands

Extinction Rebellion must recognise the impacts of colonialism and capitalism, and demand a just transition for all, argues Aranyo Aarjan

Pride in an Irish border town

This summer, Irish LGBTQ campaigner Joseph Healy joined the Pride march in his home town of Newry. Here, he explains how life on the border has changed - and the stakes of Brexit installing a hard border between Northern Ireland and the Republic


Are community land trusts a way out of the system?

People are taking charge of land and housing across the UK, posing an alternative to the commercial market. But is it enough? Hazel Sheffield reports

Real Zero

2019 has seen climate consciousness reshape the political conversation around the world, but for this new awareness to make a difference, we need to get real about targets and timescale, write Souparna Lahiri, Niclas Hällström and Rachel Rose Jackson. 

The great British land sell

Austerity and neoliberal policy-making has led to the loss of some of our greatest assets and restricted the potential for social housing. Samir Jeraj explores how this has happened and ideas of how to stop it


Radical Roots – Corbyn and the Tradition of English Radicalism

The ideas underpinning Corbynism are deeply embedded in the English radical tradition. Reclaiming this tradition can play a key part in reinvigorating our ambitions for the future. By MICHAEL CALDERBANK with HILARY WAINWRIGHT