End all immigration controls now

The No One is Illegal Group responds to Red Pepper's invitation for alternative proposals to government asylum policy.

April 1, 2004 · 3 min read

In January, Red Pepper initiated a debate on immigration controls and how to oppose them (“Taking the asylum war to Blunkett‘). In the spirit of constructive debate we at the No One is Illegal Group would like to respond.

There was much in Nigel Rose’s original article with which we agree. We agree, for example, that New Labour’s “managed migration’ policy should be opposed. Immigration control has never been about absolute exclusion; it has been about excluding the unchosen and allowing in the necessary – necessary for the British economy. This is achieved by redefining who is “legal’ and who is “illegal’. Politically, it is vital to proceed from the slogan “no one is illegal’. And this is where we diverge from Rose.

He did not demand an end to immigration control. Instead, he said: “The radical alternative, and the one that many of us feel in our hearts is the right one, is the idea of “no borders”: people should be free to go wherever they please.’ We agree with this. But why just keep to the heart? Why not say it publicly? Why not fight for no immigration controls?

Rose’s reluctance, in spite of his heart, to help build a movement for no controls is political self-censorship. People sometimes say that though they personally support a “no control’ position it is too “advanced’ to be argued publicly. It seems there is a real fear about confronting racism.

Six months ago the No One is Illegal Group wrote a manifesto with the aim, like Red Pepper, of stimulating debate. The manifesto ends with a programme of action that advocates the following:

  • To support every single campaign against deportation, and to do this on the basis of solidarity not compassion. No one needs to justify their presence.
  • To support and build every campaign against detention and removal centres, since these are among the most brutal and unjust consequences of immigration controls. No refugees or migrants should be detained simply because they want to be in this country.
  • To fight against all forms of collusion with immigration control and the Home Office. This means local authorities and voluntary sector organisations refusing to implement the government’s new poor laws: break the links between welfare entitlement and immigration status.
  • For workers within the welfare system to refuse to comply with the denial of benefits because of immigration status. Most welfare workers want to provide some form of socially useful service, but now find themselves denying services and part of the apparatus of immigration control.
  • For trade unions to embrace a position of no immigration controls. It is important to form rank and file groupings within unions of workers who are being obliged to enforce immigration controls. Non-compliance by individual workers would leave them vulnerable to victimisation and dismissal.
  • For a massive trade union campaign of recruitment of undocumented workers. This would facilitate a campaign against sweated labour and for migrant rights (eg, to a fair wage, to good working conditions and to work itself). Right now it is unlawful to work without the correct immigration documentation. It would also provide further basis for the undocumented to resist deportation and to fight for the regularisation of their status.

    Could we suggest that Red Pepper organises a debate with speakers for and against the issue of no immigration controls?

    No One Is Illegal Group



  • The radical potential of the Corbyn project

    Even worse than failing to win office would be winning it while unprepared for the realities of government. Christine Berry considers what Labour needs to do to avoid the fate of Syriza in Greece

    Photo of Boris with his hand on his head

    The crisis of Conservatism

    The Conservative Party is in a process of ideological decline or even disintegration, argue James Butler and Richard Seymour.

    Why we’ve joined the global climate strike

    Landry Ninteretse and Ian Rivera share perspectives from Kenya and the Philippines and call for universal energy systems that are clean and renewable, public and decentralised


    The World Transformed 2019

    The World Transformed, FYI

    Red Pepper’s picks of The World Transformed festival, in Brighton from 21-24 September

    photo showing posters for twt on colourful wall

    Take part in building a people’s manifesto for the movement

    Winning elections is not enough. To transform society we need to involve the people in policy making, argue Kerem Dikerdem and Annie Quick

    photo of empty school desks and large window in classroom

    This is how we build a National Education Service in the UK

    Chloe Tomlinson lays out the battle lines for a more egalitarian, democratic and holistic education system. Essential reading ahead of The World Transformed education sessions


    photo of people marching with placards

    Nurses say: Patients’ rights have no borders

    As a US-friendly no-deal Brexit inches closer, Bonnie Castillo of National Nurses United explains why US nurses have joined the fight against NHS privatisation. Recommended reading ahead of The World Transformed health sessions