In January, Red Pepper initiated a debate on immigration controls and how to oppose them (“Taking the asylum war to Blunkett‘). In the spirit of constructive debate we at the No One is Illegal Group would like to respond.
There was much in Nigel Rose’s original article with which we agree. We agree, for example, that New Labour’s “managed migration’ policy should be opposed. Immigration control has never been about absolute exclusion; it has been about excluding the unchosen and allowing in the necessary – necessary for the British economy. This is achieved by redefining who is “legal’ and who is “illegal’. Politically, it is vital to proceed from the slogan “no one is illegal’. And this is where we diverge from Rose.
He did not demand an end to immigration control. Instead, he said: “The radical alternative, and the one that many of us feel in our hearts is the right one, is the idea of “no borders”: people should be free to go wherever they please.’ We agree with this. But why just keep to the heart? Why not say it publicly? Why not fight for no immigration controls?
Rose’s reluctance, in spite of his heart, to help build a movement for no controls is political self-censorship. People sometimes say that though they personally support a “no control’ position it is too “advanced’ to be argued publicly. It seems there is a real fear about confronting racism.
Six months ago the No One is Illegal Group wrote a manifesto with the aim, like Red Pepper, of stimulating debate. The manifesto ends with a programme of action that advocates the following:
Could we suggest that Red Pepper organises a debate with speakers for and against the issue of no immigration controls?
#232: Rue Britannia ● The legacy of the British Empire ● An interview with Priyamvada Gopal ● The People’s Olympics ● An interview with Neville Southall ● Agribusiness in India ● Deliveroo’s disastrous IPO ● Latest book reviews ● And much more!
And you choose how much to pay for your subscription...
Reviewing two recent books on care in the 21st century, Emily Kenway suggests the only solution to the current crisis lies in a wholescale reorganisation of our political economy
Siobhán McGuirk and Adrienne Pine's edited volume is a powerful indictment of the modern migration complex writes Nico Vaccari
Lyn Caballero describes her experiences as a migrant domestic worker and explains why domestic workers are campaigning for immigration policy change
With casual xenophobia a comedy circuit blight, No Direction Home is a welcome tonic. Here, five troupe members explain the uses and power of laughter – and tell us some jokes
Border closures and travel restrictions caused by the pandemic have made family reunification difficult for refugees. But, as Luke Butterly reports, these rights have been eroded over a number of years
The response to the pandemic has allowed us to imagine a world without immigration detention centres, writes Rachel Harger
Want to try Red Pepper before you take out a subscription? Sign up to our newsletter and read Issue 231 for free.