Get Red Pepper's email newsletter. Enter your email address to receive our latest articles, updates and news.
Students protested the tuition fee rise in 2010 but lost momentum after, what will be the response to the Tories’ latest proposals? (Photo: Anthony Bennison, Flickr)
In 2010, the student activists who occupied Conservative HQ at the tuition fee protests were shocked by the prospect of average student debts rising to £27,000 a head. By now, we are numbed by the familiarity of austerity policies, and no riots followed George Osborne’s announcement of further changes to education funding earlier this month. But that does not mean the proposed new policies are any less nasty. In fact, the replacement of grants with loans is one of the most insidious and unjust education policies yet.
The main progressive argument against the change has been that it will put working-class students off applying to university, slowing social mobility. This argument is valuable but it is mostly speculative and not always backed up by the facts.
Research by the Independent Commission on Fees has suggested that tuition fees have not been as large a deterrent as expected to applicants from lower-income backgrounds. Though it appears counterintuitive, it is possible that the seemingly-reasonable conditions on loans have made them less of a worry to new students. Plus, of course, in this system students can replace struggle in the job market now with a struggle to repay debt later—an appealing deferral of responsibility during periods of widespread unemployment. Whatever the reason, the idea of loans-as-deterrent is not the most robust argument against them.
For anti-capitalists, there is a much stronger line of reasoning. Under the proposed system, those who cannot rely on families’ financial support, or who live in more expensive cities, will have to take out larger maintenance loans than ever before. Due to interest rates, this will lead to poorer students repaying much larger amounts of debt in the long term than those who can afford to pay for living costs and fees upfront. As anti-fees campaigner James Elliott puts it, the interest accrued over time is ‘effectively a charge on the student for being from a low-income family.’ The problem is only exacerbated for poorer students who tend to lack the cultural capital required to enter the elite after graduation.
What is more, if in a few years the Tories privatise the student loan book, as they tried to do in 2013, the money being taken from lower-salaried, more indebted graduates will go straight into the hands of whichever large shareholders the Conservatives select to take control of the debt. This facilitates the long-term movement of money upwards through the class system, ensuring the majority of graduates remain debtors to a few increasingly wealthy creditors. Even if the Government retains ownership of the loan book, their financial model performs the same role that privatisation would: reversing social democratic gains and shoring up the wealth of investors and high-earners.
For many, the reworking of the student loans package barely registers on the Richter scale of austerity measures in Osborne’s budget. But for students—and anyone who values education and its role in critical thought—it is essential we fight it.
The question remains: how do you fight such a relentless Government? The furious response to the 2010 hike in tuition fees was likely absorbed by the Liberal Democrats’ election collapse. But beyond that protests have not been effective, whether in Parliament or on the streets. Now we have a choice: either we follow the usual paths, gathering people to attend demonstrations and leaving it at that, or we stop to consider fresher, more creative strategies.
One way to plan the next few years’ resistance is to look to more successful comrades around the world. The Quebec student movement has had considerably more success than our own in challenging attacks on education. In line with other neoliberal governments, Quebec’s Liberals announced a potential tuition fee hike in 2012. The student movement reacted quickly, most notably the group ASSÉ (Association pour une solidarité syndicale étudiante), a radical student union to the left of our National Union of Students (NUS). After they began to protest, the government issued emergency legislation (Bill 78) to stop the resistance. Instead, it triggered huge civil disobedience, especially from students. After months of protest, Bill 78 was reversed, tuition fees frozen, and a groundswell of dissent helped oust the Liberals power in the National Assembly.
Across the pond, British student activists gazed on in amazement, all asking the same questions: how did they do it? How did they mobilise so many people? What could we learn from them?
For some in the UK, the success of Quebec’s student movement appeared to emerge from a unique social context which we could not mimic. Quebec has a historic culture of protest based in student uprisings of 1968. But when I spoke to Jérémie Bédard-Wien, former spokesperson for ASSÉ, he seemed reluctant to accept this essentialist explanation. In his words: “Quebec students are not born revolutionaries.” For Jérémie, the key to success in 2012 was in student activists’ efforts at movement-building before protests began. Many people spent months leafleting, holding democratic meetings and discussions, getting into persuasive arguments with their peers and keeping energy as high as they could.
Just as important, Quebec managed to mobilise outside student circles for their anti-fees protests. Rather than looking on as students rioted, perhaps sympathetic but too out-of-the-loop to join in, workers in Quebec were brought into the struggle through links to trade unions. Neoliberal changes to funding in the education sector (including cuts and privatisation) affect university staff as well as students, especially at the lower end of the payscale. They have reason to be allies in the fight to keep education publicly-funded and indeed some of the largest trade unions joined the protests. Commentator such as Richard Seymour were quick to highlight these relationships. UK students can work towards this same unity by engaging with unions like the UCU, forging links with tutors and support staff who stand against tuition fees, and ensuring our own organising techniques make meetings open and accessible to all, not just students with free afternoons.
One of the most successful tactics in Quebec was the student strike, a strategy that has fallen out of use in British student politics. Bédard-Wien explained that student strikes work by being “economically threatening”. If enough students join in and for long enough, a strike “delays the entry of an entire graduating class into the job market”, forcing seminars to be rescheduled and lecturers paid twice for their work. They also provide a platform where students can organise, by freeing them up to attend discussions and think about ways of advancing the situation. However, student strikes require even larger turnouts than workers’ strikes since students are not withholding labour while they are at university. Their leverage is much longer-term.
Our NUS is unlikely to be the vehicle for delivering this kind of strike. Late last year, they even refused to back a far less radical protest. The inner workings of the NUS do not begin to resemble the direct democracy and grassroots organising that Bédard-Wien advocates. However, the UK does have a student-led group that more closely fits the bill: the National Campaign Against Fees and Cuts (NCAFC). Established in the wake of the 2010 tuition fee protests, NCAFC comes with less baggage and bureaucracy than the NUS, though it has its own challenges: it is too small as yet to feel properly democratic and conferences are ramshackle and irregular.
Nevertheless, NCAFC members are keen to take on Quebec’s lessons. At a NCAFC annual conference last year, one member proposed student strikes as a viable option for the UK. NCAFC is now beginning to plan for student strikes in the near future – including at its summer training weekend in early September. This is something student activists should consider attending.
Since NCAFC was founded, a country closer to home than Quebec has seen resistance to the idea of tuition fees. In 2014, after just over a decade of charging fees, Germany decided to scrap them, even in conservative southern states like Bavaria. Activist and writer Deborah Hermanns noted that ‘the German student movement won in large part because it kept going and didn’t compromise.’ She suggests that organising around a single, clear demand—‘free education’—is key to maintaining clarity and building support. Anything less can lead to compromises, such as Labour’s £6,000 fee pledge at the last election, a promise which missed the point by accepting the individualistic, market-driven Tory conception of education which student activists fiercely oppose.
Hermanns also suggests that Germany’s student unions are generally more effective structures for working towards change than the UK’s. In Germany, she describes student unions that are still considered political bodies to represent students’ interests, rather than the service providers which UK unions have increasingly become. Perhaps the UK needs a cultural shift, a move to viewing education as a universal right, not a privilege which individuals undertake to advance their careers.
Barbara Kehm, an expert in higher education leadership and strategy, claims that a more socialistic concept of education is strong in Germany—that is, it is seen as a source of collective value which deserves public funding. Maybe much of the work we need to do is on the conceptual level. We must focus on changing minds, challenging the marketised model of education as a means of competitive individual gain, and pointing out the economic flaws and ideological motivations of the new fees system.
This is part of the ‘groundwork’ Bédard-Wien talked about—changing minds and hearts in the wider population. For this task, slogans are not enough. Bédard-Wien told me that ASSÉ partly achieved their goals by carefully considering the language of speeches and manifestos, refusing to fall back simply on the language of left and right which can make movements readily dismissible. ASSÉ focused on how to appeal to a broad audience’s assumptions about the world without conceding any radicalism. Like Podemos and Syriza, they did not fit easily into entrenched political stereotypes. We can learn from this too. Thinking about presentation does not have to be a form of compromise.
NCAFC have planned a demonstration on Wednesday November 4, which gives the student movement time to ruminate. Undoubtedly, the march will be tense, there will be widespread frustration and a strong desire for direct action. Many will yearn for a repeat of Millbank, hoping for the taste of freedom which destructive resistance can provide—at least temporarily. But we must ask what we want, and indeed what we can get, from disruptive protests.
As Hermanns reminds us: tuition fees are not an inevitability. It doesn’t have to end here. I was disappointed but unsurprised that German students’ tactics seemed so intangible, and that Bédard-Wien did not have any miracle solutions from Quebec. Yet I know there are no miracles in politics. If something seems incredible, someone somewhere probably worked for it. It is time to build, and it is time to think: about student strikes, disruptive protest, organising with unions, changing wider narratives about education and reassessing our own language. These are by no means the only suggestions. What is certain is that we need to come up with something new.
Kate Bradley is a recent graduate and member of NCAFC
The police spend little of their time making arrests, and most crimes are not solved, writes Alex Vitale – their real purpose is social control
Many important things happened on conference floor, reports Alex Nunns – but you wouldn’t know it from reading the newspapers
Radhika Desai says Capital by Karl Marx is still an essential read on the 150th anniversary of its publication
The Spanish state is seizing ballot papers and raiding meetings, write Ignasi Bernat and David Whyte – but it is being met with united resistance
The crunch executive meeting ahead of Labour conference agreed some welcome changes, writes Michael Calderbank, but there is still much further to go
Dipesh Pandya speaks to documentary film-maker Sanjay Kak, who for 30 years has been working outside the mainstream to tell a story rooted in the struggles of those excluded by India’s militarism and its narrative of neoliberal growth
Jeremy Gilbert on how radical Labour politics can be inspired by the utopianism of the counterculture
Disasters have unequal impacts – it's the poor and marginalised who suffer most. David Harvey writes on Hurricane Harvey
#MeToo is necessary – but I’m sick of having to prove my humanity
Women are expected to reveal personal trauma to be taken seriously, writes Eleanor Penny
Universal credit isn’t about saving money – it’s about disciplining unemployed people
The scheme has cost a fortune and done nothing but cause suffering. So why does it exist at all? Tom Walker digs into universal credit’s origins in Tory ideology
Meet the digital feminists
We're building new online tools to create a new feminist community and tackle sexism wherever we find it, writes Franziska Grobke
The Marikana women’s fight for justice, five years on
Marienna Pope-Weidemann meets Sikhala Sonke, a grassroots social justice group led by the women of Marikana
Forget ‘Columbus Day’ – this is the Day of Indigenous Resistance
By Leyli Horna, Marcela Terán and Sebastián Ordonez for Wretched of the Earth
Uber and the corporate capture of e-petitions
Steve Andrews looks at a profit-making petition platform's questionable relationship with the cab company
You might be a centrist if…
What does 'centrist' mean? Tom Walker identifies the key markers to help you spot centrism in the wild
Black Journalism Fund Open Editorial Meeting in Leeds
Friday 13th October, 5pm to 7pm, meeting inside the Laidlaw Library, Leeds University
This leadership contest can transform Scottish Labour
Martyn Cook argues that with a new left-wing leader the Scottish Labour Party can make a comeback
Review: No Is Not Enough
Samir Dathi reviews No Is Not Enough: Defeating the New Shock Politics, by Naomi Klein
Building Corbyn’s Labour from the ground up: How ‘the left’ won in Hackney South
Heather Mendick has gone from phone-banker at Corbyn for Leader to Hackney Momentum organiser to secretary of her local party. Here, she shares her top tips on transforming Labour from the bottom up
Five things to know about the independence movement in Catalonia
James O'Nions looks at the underlying dynamics of the Catalan independence movement
‘This building will be a library!’ From referendum to general strike in Catalonia
Ignasi Bernat and David Whyte report from the Catalan general strike, as the movements prepare to build a new republic
Chlorine chickens are just the start: Liam Fox’s Brexit trade free-for-all
A hard-right free marketer is now in charge of our trade policy. We urgently need to develop an alternative vision, writes Nick Dearden
There is no ‘cult of Corbyn’ – this is a movement preparing for power
The pundits still don’t understand that Labour’s new energy is about ‘we’ not ‘me’, writes Hilary Wainwright
Debt relief for the hurricane-hit islands is the least we should do
As the devastation from recent hurricanes in the Caribbean becomes clearer, the calls for debt relief for affected countries grow stronger, writes Tim Jones
‘Your credit score is not sufficient to enter this location’: the risks of the ‘smart city’
Jathan Sadowski explains techno-political trends of exclusion and enforcement in our cities, and how to overcome this new type of digital oppression
Why I’m standing with pregnant women and resisting NHS passport checks
Dr Joanna Dobbin says the government is making migrant women afraid to seek healthcare, increasing their chances of complications or even death
‘Committees in Defence of the Referendum’: update from Catalonia
Ignasi Bernat and David Whyte on developments as the Catalan people resist the Spanish state's crackdown on their independence referendum
The rights and safety of LGBTQ+ people are not guaranteed – we must continue to fight for them
Kennedy Walker looks at the growth in hate attacks at a time when the Tory government is being propped up by homophobes
Naomi Klein: the Corbyn movement is part of a global phenomenon
What radical writer Naomi Klein said in her guest speech to Labour Party conference
Waiting for the future to begin: refugees’ everyday lives in Greece
Solidarity volunteer Karolina Partyga on what she has learned from refugees in Thessaloniki
Don’t let Uber take you for a ride
Uber is no friend of passengers or workers, writes Lewis Norton – the firm has put riders at risk and exploited its drivers
Acid Corbynism’s next steps: building a socialist dance culture
Matt Phull and Will Stronge share more thoughts about the postcapitalist potential of the Acid Corbynist project
Flooding the cradle of civilisation: A 12,000 year old town in Kurdistan battles for survival
It’s one of the oldest continually inhabited places on earth, but a new dam has put Hasankeyf under threat, write Eliza Egret and Tom Anderson
New model activism: Putting Labour in office and the people in power
Hilary Wainwright examines how the ‘new politics’ needs to be about both winning electoral power and building transformative power
What is ‘free movement plus’?
A new report proposes an approach that can push back against the tide of anti-immigrant sentiment. Luke Cooper explains
The World Transformed: Red Pepper’s pick of the festival
Red Pepper is proud to be part of organising The World Transformed, in Brighton from 23-26 September. Here are our highlights from the programme
Working class theatre: Save Our Steel takes the stage
A new play inspired by Port Talbot’s ‘Save Our Steel’ campaign asks questions about the working class leaders of today. Adam Johannes talks to co-director Rhiannon White about the project, the people and the politics behind it
The dawn of commons politics
As supporters of the new 'commons politics' win office in a variety of European cities, Stacco Troncoso and Ann Marie Utratel chart where this movement came from – and where it may be going