Get Red Pepper's email newsletter. Enter your email address to receive our latest articles, updates and news.

×

Spoiling for Choice

The Labour-Tory market model for extending choice in the NHS will inevitably result in a dramatic decline in service-user equity. Here Marian Barnes outlines reforms that would benefit everybody.

August 1, 2004
4 min read

The sight of Tony Blair competing with Michael Howard over who could offer most choice to consumers of health services revealed just how threadbare New Labour’s vision for the development of public services is. Far more fertile ideas about improving services have come from the collective campaigning of the people who provide and, most pertinently, use services.

Choice cannot be the mechanism for empowering users or transforming services, because it does not engage with the way in which people use them. Choice per se is rarely experienced as empowering. Health services are often used at times when people are anxious, afraid and/or have come to the limits of their own capacities to resolve their problems. The offer of choice can contribute further anxiety: if you make the wrong choice you”ve only got yourself to blame if things don’t work out. Where people use services for a long time or at frequent intervals they can become experts well capable of deciding the best option for them. But in such circumstances continuity may be as important as, and maybe even more important than, choice. And what about those situations in which service use is a collective rather than individual experience? Relationships between service users attending day centres or living in residential accommodation can be as important as the formal service in determining satisfaction. Promoting individual choice can undermine the collective experience of building relationships with other service users.

There is a wealth of examples showing that when service users act collectively to improve health services what they seek is not choice but voice: a voice that would influence how and what services are delivered. Older people who made considerable use of health and social care services in Fife, for example, were supported by Age Concern to develop their own ideas about service design and delivery: shared experiences of insensitive practice around hospital discharge were transformed into a 14-point “good hospital-discharge plan” that formed the basis of joint working to improve procedure. Elsewhere, mental health patients in Birmingham developed criteria for assessing the responsiveness of services and were then commissioned by the local mental health trust to review a range of services against those criteria. User members of a patients” panel at a GP surgery in Liverpool came up with proposals for reducing the number of missed appointments by making it easier for people to cancel appointments they could no longer make. And in Salford patients of two primary care practices joined with health service professionals to create a governing body responsible for determining priorities and overseeing service improvements.

In all these examples service users worked collectively and drew on their own expertise and knowledge to contribute to service improvement. The emphasis was not on securing ways in which service users could choose which hospital they went to, or which doctor attended them, but on improving the services they already use – for their own benefit and the benefit of other users. Sometimes the improvements resulting from such an approach are modest and the people involved can be frustrated by the slow rate of progress. But there is also evidence of service improvement, and of increased trust between users and providers deriving from the experience of working together.

Why does the government fail to recognise the significance of such developments? Why doesn’t it build policies based on the principle of collective action, which will both improve public services and create relationships of reciprocal trust between public services and their users? In other contexts, as with strategies for neighbourhood renewal, these are exactly the sort of initiative that is being promoted. Yet when it comes to health and education the government wants to enable the middle classes to use services in the same way they buy a holiday or pay for a solicitor.

Encouraging poor communities to overcome the disadvantages they face seems to be one thing, but when it comes to persuading middle England not to abandon public healthcare and education the rules are different. Rather than promote the notion that health and education are genuinely public services, New Labour wants to pretend they are the same as services in the private sector. How does this contribute to public service renewal?Marian Barnes is professor of social research at the University of Birmingham’s Institute of Applied Social Studies. Her publications include Care, Communities and Citizens (Longman) and (with Ric Bowl) Taking Over the Asylum: empowerment and mental health (Palgrave)

Red Pepper is an independent, non-profit magazine that puts left politics and culture at the heart of its stories. We think publications should embrace the values of a movement that is unafraid to take a stand, radical yet not dogmatic, and focus on amplifying the voices of the people and activists that make up our movement. If you think so too, please support Red Pepper in continuing our work by becoming a subscriber today.
Why not try our new pay as you feel subscription? You decide how much to pay.

The new municipalism is part of a proud radical history
Molly Conisbee reflects on the history of citizens taking collective control of local services

With the rise of Corbyn, is there still a place for the Green Party?
Former Green principal speaker Derek Wall says the party may struggle in the battle for votes, but can still be important in the battle of ideas

Fearless Cities: the new urban movements
A wave of new municipalist movements has been experimenting with how to take – and transform – power in cities large and small. Bertie Russell and Oscar Reyes report on the growing success of radical urban politics around the world

A musical fightback against school arts cuts
Elliot Clay on why his new musical turns the spotlight on the damage austerity has done to arts education, through the story of one school band's battle

Neoliberalism: the break-up tour
Sarah Woods and Andrew Simms ask why, given the trail of destruction it has left, we are still dancing to the neoliberal tune

Cat Smith MP: ‘Jeremy Corbyn has authenticity. You can’t fake that’
Cat Smith, shadow minister for voter engagement and youth affairs and one of the original parliamentary backers of Corbyn’s leadership, speaks to Ashish Ghadiali

To stop the BBC interviewing climate deniers, we need to make climate change less boring
To stop cranks like Lord Lawson getting airtime, we need to provoke more interesting debates around climate change than whether it's real or not, writes Leo Barasi

Tory Glastonbury? Money can’t buy you cultural relevance
Adam Peggs on why the left has more fun

Essay: After neoliberalism, what next?
There are economically-viable, socially-desirable alternatives to the failed neoliberal economic model, writes Jayati Ghosh

With the new nuclear ban treaty, it’s time to scrap Trident – and spend the money on our NHS
As a doctor, I want to see money spent on healthcare not warfare, writes David McCoy - Britain should join the growing international movement for disarmament

Inglorious Empire: What the British Did to India
Inglorious Empire: What the British Did to India, by Shashi Tharoor, reviewed by Ian Sinclair

A Death Retold in Truth and Rumour
A Death Retold in Truth and Rumour: Kenya, Britain and the Julie Ward Murder, by Grace A Musila, reviewed by Allen Oarbrook

‘We remembered that convictions can inspire and motivate people’: interview with Lisa Nandy MP
The general election changed the rules, but there are still tricky issues for Labour to face, Lisa Nandy tells Ashish Ghadiali

Everything you know about Ebola is wrong
Vicky Crowcroft reviews Ebola: How a People’s Science Helped End an Epidemic, by Paul Richards

Job vacancy: Red Pepper is looking for an online editor
Closing date for applications: 1 September.

Theresa May’s new porn law is ridiculous – but dangerous
The law is almost impossible to enforce, argues Lily Sheehan, but it could still set a bad precedent

Interview: Queer British Art
James O'Nions talks to author Alex Pilcher about the Tate’s Queer British Art exhibition and her book A Queer Little History of Art

Cable the enabler: new Lib Dem leader shows a party in crisis
Vince Cable's stale politics and collusion with the Conservatives belong in the dustbin of history, writes Adam Peggs

Anti-Corbyn groupthink and the media: how pundits called the election so wrong
Reporting based on the current consensus will always vastly underestimate the possibility of change, argues James Fox

Michael Cashman: Commander of the Blairite Empire
Lord Cashman, a candidate in Labour’s internal elections, claims to stand for Labour’s grassroots members. He is a phony, writes Cathy Cole

Contribute to Conter – the new cross-party platform linking Scottish socialists
Jonathan Rimmer, editor of Conter, says it’s time for a new non-sectarian space for Scottish anti-capitalists and invites you to take part

Editorial: Empire will eat itself
Ashish Ghadiali introduces the June/July issue of Red Pepper

Eddie Chambers: Black artists and the DIY aesthetic
Eddie Chambers, artist and art historian, speaks to Ashish Ghadiali about the cultural strategies that he, as founder of the Black Art Group, helped to define in the 1980s

Despite Erdogan, Turkey is still alive
With this year's referendum consolidating President Erdogan’s autocracy in Turkey, Nazim A argues that the way forward for democrats lies in a more radical approach

Red Pepper Race Section: open editorial meeting – 11 August in Leeds
The next open editorial meeting of the Red Pepper Race Section will take place between 3.30-5.30pm, Friday 11th August in Leeds.

Mogg-mentum? Thatcherite die-hard Jacob Rees-Mogg is no man of the people
Adam Peggs says Rees-Mogg is no joke – he is a living embodiment of Britain's repulsive ruling elite

Power to the renters: Turning the tide on our broken housing system
Heather Kennedy, from the Renters Power Project, argues it’s time to reject Thatcher’s dream of a 'property-owning democracy' and build renters' power instead

Your vote can help Corbyn supporters win these vital Labour Party positions
Left candidate Seema Chandwani speaks to Red Pepper ahead of ballot papers going out to all members for a crucial Labour committee

Join the Rolling Resistance to the frackers
Al Wilson invites you to take part in a month of anti-fracking action in Lancashire with Reclaim the Power

The Grenfell public inquiry must listen to the residents who have been ignored for so long
Councils handed housing over to obscure, unaccountable organisations, writes Anna Minton – now we must hear the voices they silenced