About us   Get involved   Subscribe   Latest print issue

Comprehensive health check

Dr Wendy Savage reviews Socialist Register 2010: Morbid Symptoms - Health under Capitalism (Leo Panitch and Colin Leys (eds) Merlin Press, 2009)

As a newcomer to the Socialist Register I found this a fascinating and illuminating book. The 19 authors come from nine different countries, from North America to China, Finland to Tanzania, and from diverse academic disciplines. The essays are well-referenced, making it a useful source for activists who are fighting the privatisation by stealth of our NHS.

Colin Leys starts off with a critique of the argument that the increasing life expectancy that began in the 19th century was a result of the growth of capitalism. He discusses the way new drugs and research changed health care in the 20th century, and ends with a look at how big business is currently infiltrating health care in England. He, like myself, dismisses the argument that the demand for health care is infinite.

Several chapters tackle inequalities in health, the commodification of health care, marketisation in Europe and the problems facing those in the US who want to see radical reform of their ailing, expensive and inequitable system.

Paula Tibendage and Maureen Mackintosh look at the appalling maternal mortality rate in Africa and the failure of attempts to lower it. They argue for a systemic way to tackle this longstanding problem, which requires a culture shift towards the value of women in society. Robert Albritton describes the way the food industry contributes to the epidemic of obesity while a quarter of the world's population has insufficient food - a hidden epidemic of starvation.

The sections on global health policy, public health, the WHO 'Health for All' initiative and contributions about China and Cuba are all informative and thought-provoking. Lesley Henderson's analysis of the role of TV medical dramas throws a new light on these popular series. And, lastly, Julian Tudor Hart considers 'Mental health in a sick society', an answer to Prozac Nation.

I thoroughly recommend this book for all those who care about health and our NHS. It is educational but also easy to read.

share


1 comment

stephen ernest smith says:

The entire world may not be aware of the surrender of Barack Obama and the reversion of the U.S. Government to the Bush era that took place in the final weeks of 2010. In a mere 11 days Obama cut a deal w/conservatives that will keep taxes low for the rich for at least two years, raises thd deficit by 885 billion dollars and saps resources of the already sapped Social Security program for the elderly. It was capitalism at its most craven. The unemployed got help but at a terrible price. Ironically, US capitalism survives ONLY with Chinese communist loans. Is this not indicative of something?

leave a comment

January 2010


latest from red pepper


A different way of doing things Robin Murray explores the potential of co-ops to form the basis of an alternative economy

A bank worth backing Christopher Hird looks at how the Co-op Bank has fared in the financial crisis

One Million Climate Jobs: An interview with John Stewart Tom Robinson talks to the Chair of the Campaign Against Climate Change on how the creation of one million climate jobs could help save the economy and the environment

Co-operatise the state? Can the co-op movement be one source of alternatives to marketisation? Hilary Wainwright explores

It’s all at the co-op Jim Keogan reports on how co-ops are combining economic resilience with egalitarianism




Red Pepper is a magazine of political rebellion and dissent, influenced by socialism, feminism and green politics. more »

Get a free sample copy of Red Pepper

invest in red pepper

Looking for an 'AAA-rated' investment?* Red Pepper has one for you.

Unlike most European economies, Red Pepper has a serious strategy for growth. We're recruting a politcal organiser to expand our readership and subscriber base. Help us raise the money to do so.

* Rated AAA for Anti-Austerity Activism

ads


The UK's leading supplier of Fair Trade products



get updates

Get our email newsletter, with news, offers, updates and competitions.
help red pepper

Become a Friend of Red Pepper
Help keep Red Pepper afloat with a regular donation

Watch films online
See free trailers and support Red Pepper by streaming the full films:
Cocaine Unwrapped
The War You Don't See